THE POLISH-UKRAINIAN ALLIANCE OF 1920 IN CONTEMPORARY UKRAINIAN HISTORIOGRAPHY
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.15407/mzu2024.33.337Keywords:
Polish-Ukrainian Alliance of 1920, Polish-Soviet war, S. Petliura, J. Piłsudski, historiographyAbstract
The article is devoted to the study of the development and main trends of modern Ukrainian historiography of the Polish-Ukrainian Alliance of 1920. The source base of the study are monographs, articles, and dissertations of Ukrainian historians in the period from 1991 to 2022. The methodological basis of the study is the principles of the Cambridge School of Intellectual History, which can be generally characterized as a contextualist method of interpretation, which places the main emphasis on historical conditions and the intellectual context of the discourse of a given historical era. These principles are especially relevant for the mentioned issue given its political sensitivity, which has not disappeared to this day. As a result, the political context at the time of the creation of the text can significantly influence the research questions and interpretations of the researchers.
The author notes that since Ukraine regained its independence in 1991, Ukrainian scholars have rejected the Soviet paradigm of the history of the Polish-Soviet war and have largely adopted the interpretive schemes of emigration historiography. In this narrative, in contrast to the Soviet one, S. Petliura, when signing the agreement with Poland, was guided by Ukrainian national interests. However, Ukraine became a hostage to the selfish interests of Poland, which eventually betrayed its ally. However, as the author proves, the interpretive model that depicts the Polish-Ukrainian Alliance as the resultant force of Polish and Ukrainian interests and resources is beginning to dominate Ukrainian historiography. The aspect of uniting for the common struggle against Bolshevism began to come to the fore. A significant role in this process is played by the possibility of contacts between Ukrainian historians and Polish colleagues, the essential filling of many factual gaps and, not least, the geopolitical situation of Ukraine.
Downloads
References
Aleksiyevetsʹ, L. (2007). Polʹshcha v 1918-1926 rr.: osoblyvosti vidrodzhennya natsionalʹnoyi derzhavnosti, formuvannya suspilʹno-politychnoho ustroyu. Extended abstract of Doctor's thesis. Chernivtsi [in Ukrainian].
Bodnar, V. (2019). Vstupne slovo. Ukrayina i Polʹshcha: Shlyakhamy mizhderzhavnykh vzayemyn : zb. nauk. pratsʹ z nahody 100-richchya vstanovlennya polʹsʹko-ukrayinsʹkykh dyplomatychnykh vidnosyn. Kyiv [in Ukrainian].
Borymskyi, V. (2015). Polʹsʹko-ukrayinsʹkyy soyuz 1920 r. v ukrayinsʹkiy i polʹsʹkiy istoriohrafiyakh. Extended abstract of PhD thesis. Cherkasy [in Ukrainian].
Borymskyi, V. (2021). The Polish-Ukrainian Alliance of 1920 in the Polish Public Discourse During the Interwar period. Skhidnoievropeiskyi Istorychnyi Visnyk, 19, 136-146 [in English].
Borymskyi, V. (2022). The Polish-Ukrainian Alliance of 1920 and White Russia. The Polish Review, 67 (2), 64-85 [in English].
https://doi.org/10.5406/23300841.67.2.04
Bruski, J.J., & Werstiuk, W. (2020). Przedmowa. Sojusz Piłsudski-Petlura. Dokumenty i materiały. Warszawa-Kijów [in Ukrainian].
Datskiv, I. (2009). Dyplomatiya ukrayinsʹkykh derzhavnykh utvorenʹ u zakhysty natsionalʹnykh interesiv. 1917-1923 rr. Ternopilʹ [in Ukrainian].
Datskiv, I. (2009). Varshavsʹka uhoda 1920 r. Naukovi zoshyty istorychnoho fakulʹtetu Lʹvivsʹkoho universytetu. Zbirnyk naukovykh pratsʹ, 10, 65-72 [in Ukrainian].
Datskiv, I. (2010). Dyplomatiya ukrayinsʹkykh natsionalʹnykh uryadiv u zakhysti derzhavnosti (1917 - 1923 rr.). Doctor's thesis. Kyiv [in Ukrainian].
Derzhalyuk, M. (1998). Mizhnarodne stanovyshche Ukrayiny ta yiyi vyzvolʹna borotʹba u 1917-1922 rokakh. Kyiv [in Ukrainian].
Dovhan, YU. (2006). Polityka Frantsiyi, Velykoyi Brytaniyi ta SSHA shchodo natsionalʹnoyi derzhavnosti Ukrayiny v 1917-1920 rr. u vitchyznyaniy ta ukrayinsʹkiy zarubizhniy istoriohrafiyakh. Extended abstract of PhD thesis. Kyiv [in Ukrainian].
Dysertatsiyi po problemakh Ukrayinsʹkoyi revolyutsiyi, zakhyshcheni v Ukrayini v 1991-2001 rr. (2002). Problemy vyvchennya istoriyi Ukrayinsʹkoyi revolyutsiyi 1917-1921 rokiv, 1, 279-294 [in Ukrainian].
Dysertatsiyi z problem istoriyi Ukrayinsʹkoyi revolyutsiyi, zakhyshcheni v 2006-2011 rokakh, (2011). Problemy vyvchennya istoriyi Ukrayinsʹkoyi revolyutsiyi 1917-1921 rokiv, 6, 408-430 [in Ukrainian].
Holubko, V. (2003). Polʹsʹko-radyansʹka viyna 1920 r. v otsinkakh zakhidnoukrayinsʹkykh politykiv. Naukovi zoshyty istorychnoho fakulʹtetu Lʹvivsʹkoho natsionalʹnoho universytetu imeni Ivana Franka, 5-6, 177-187 [in Ukrainian].
Hrytsak, YA. (1996). Narys istoriyi Ukrayiny: formuvannya modernoyi ukrayinsʹkoyi natsiyi XIX - XX st. Kyiv [in Ukrainian].
Hudʹ, B. (2000). Ukrayintsi-Polyaky: khto vynen? U poshuku prychyn ukrayinsʹko-polʹsʹkykh konfliktiv pershoyi pol. XX st. Lʹviv [in Ukrainian].
Hudʹ, B. (2008). Ukrayinsʹko-polʹsʹki konflikty XIX-pershoyi polovyny XX stolittya: etnosotsialʹnyy aspekt. Extended abstract of Doctor's thesis. Lʹviv [in Ukrainian].
Hudʹ, B., & Holubko, V. (1997). Nelehka doroha do porozuminnya. Do pytannya henezy ukrayinsʹko-polʹsʹkoho viysʹkovo-politychnoho sprivrobitnytstva 1917-1921 rr. Lʹviv [in Ukrainian].
Humenyuk, O. (2020). Molodizhni orhanizatsiyi v taborakh internovanoyi Armiyi Ukrayinsʹkoyi Narodnoyi Respubliky v Polʹshchi. Polʹshcha i Ukrayina: Problemy ta perspektyvy: monohrafiya. Krakiv [in Ukrainian].
Istoriya Ukrayiny: nove bachennya. (1996). (Vol.2). Kyiv [in Ukrainian].
Kalakura, O. (1999). Akt zluky v konteksti ukrayinsʹko-polʹsʹkykh vidnosyn. Ukrayinsʹka sobornistʹ: ideya, dosvid, problemy: (Do 80-richchya Aktu Zluky 22 sich. 1919 r.). Kyiv [in Ukrainian].
Kapelyushnyy, V. (2003). Zdobuta i vtrachena nezalezhnistʹ: Istoriohrafichnyy narys ukrayinsʹkoyi derzhavnosti doby natsionalʹno-vyzvolʹnykh zmahanʹ (1917-1921 rr.). Kyiv [in Ukrainian].
Kapelyushnyy, V. (2004). Ukrayinsʹka natsionalʹna derzhavnistʹ doby vyzvolʹnykh zmahanʹ (1917-1921 rr. ). Extended abstract of Doctor's thesis. Kyiv [in Ukrainian].
Kasʹyanov, H. (2020). Ukraynskaya revolyutsyya y polʹsʹko-ukraynskyy soyuz 1920 h., Sojusz Piłsudski-Petlura w kontekście politycznej i militarnej walki o kształt Europy Wschodniej. Lublin-Warszawa [in Russian].
Kharuk, A. (2000). Viysʹkovo-povitryani syly Ukrayiny v 1917-1920 rr. Extended abstract of PhD thesis. Lʹviv [in Ukrainian].
Korolʹov, H., & Skalʹsʹkyy, V., (2020). Mizhnarodna naukova e-konferentsiya Soyuz Pilsudsʹkoho - Petlyury z pohlyadu stolittya. Ukrayinsʹkyy istorychnyy zhurnal, 2, 234-235 [in Ukrainian].
Kostyshyn, E. (2011). Viysʹkovo-politychna diyalʹnistʹ Symona Petlyury. Extended abstract of PhD thesis. Lʹviv [in Ukrainian].
Kovalʹchuk, M. (2005). Ukrayinsʹka viysʹkova misiya v Polʹshchi (lypenʹ-lystopad 1920 r.). Ukrayina dyplomatychna, 6, 382-406 [in Ukrainian].
Krasivsʹkyy, O. (2008). Ukrayinsʹko-polʹsʹki vzayemyny v 1917-1923 rr. Kyiv [in Ukrainian].
Krushynsʹkyy, V., & Levenetsʹ, YU. (1993). Istoriya Ukrayiny. Kyiv [in Ukrainian].
Kryvyzyuk, L. (2006). Vyshkil ta vykhovna robota v ukrayinsʹkykh viysʹkakh periodu vyzvolʹnykh zmahanʹ 1917-1920 rr. Extended abstract of PhD thesis. Kyiv [in Ukrainian].
Kucher, T. (1999). Varshavsʹka uhoda 21 kvitnya 1920 r. Istorychna shkola profesora Volodymyra Zadorozhnoho, 1, 122-127 [in Ukrainian].
Lavretsʹkyy, R. (2009). Ukrayinsʹko-polʹsʹko-bilʹshovytsʹka viyna 1920 roku v suchasniy ukrayinsʹkiy ta polʹsʹkiy istoriohrafiyakh, Ukrayina: kulʹturna spadshchyna, natsionalʹna svidomistʹ, derzhavnistʹ, 18, 652-665 [in Ukrainian].
Lisevych, I. (2002). U vidblysku polʹsʹkykh bahnetiv. Zhyttya Kyyeva pidchas perebuvannya v nʹomu polʹsʹkykh viysʹk (travenʹ-chervenʹ 1920 r.). Kyiv [in Ukrainian].
Lytvyn, M., & Khakhula, L. (2020). Soyuz Petlyury - Pilsudsʹkoho: vidznachennya 100-richchya v Ukrayini ta Polʹshchi. Ukrayinsʹkyy istorychnyy zhurnal, 6, 234-235 [in Ukrainian].
Lytvyn, S. (2001). Sud istoriyi. Symon Petlyura i Petlyuriana. Kyiv [in Ukrainian].
Lytvyn, V. (2003). Tvoryty Ukrayinu Velyku. Kyiv [in Ukrainian].
Lytvyn, V. (2003). Ukrayina: Doba viyn i revolyutsiy (1914-1920). Kyiv [in Ukrainian].
Lytvyn, V. (2008). Istoriya Ukrayiny. Kyiv [in Ukrainian].
Matyash, I. (2019). Pochatok instytutsiynoyi istoriyi ukrayinsʹko-polʹsʹkykh dyplomatychnykh vidnosyn. Ukrayina i Polʹshcha: Shlyakhamy mizhderzhavnykh vzayemyn. Kyiv [in Ukrainian].
Matyash, I. (2020). Politychno-dyplomatychnyy uspikh chy velykyy proval: Otsinky Varshavsʹkoho dohovoru 1920 roku ukrayinsʹkymy dyplomatamy. Przegląd Wschodni, XVI, 1 (61), 103-113 [in Ukrainian].
Mykhaylova, O. (2005). Polʹsʹko ukrayinsʹkyy perehovornyy protses ta pidpysannya Varshavsʹkoho dohovoru (berezenʹ-kvitenʹ 1920 r.). Ukrayina XX st.: kulʹtura, ideolohiya, polityka, 9, 154-175 [in Ukrainian].
Mykhaylova, O. (2011). Lysty Andriya Livytsʹkoho pro polʹsʹko-ukrayinsʹki perehovory u Varshavi (kinetsʹ 1919 - kvitenʹ 1920 rokiv). Studiyi z istoriyi Ukrayinsʹkoyi revolyutsiyi 1917-1921 rokiv. Kyiv [in Ukrainian].
Mykhaylova, O. (2011). Polʹsʹko-ukrayinsʹkyy soyuz 1920 r.: viysʹkovo-hospodarcha spivpratsya na terytoriyi Pravoberezhnoyi Ukrayiny (kinetsʹ kvitnya - seredyna chervnya). Problemy vyvchennya istoriyi Ukrayinsʹkoyi revolyutsiyi 1917-1921 rr., 6, 295-337 [in Ukrainian].
Myna, Zh. (2007). Zbroyni syly Dyrektoriyi UNR ta yikh borotʹba za derzhavnu nezalezhnistʹ Ukrayiny (lystopad 1918 r. - lystopad 1920 r.). Extended abstract of PhD thesis. Lʹviv [in Ukrainian].
Nahayevsʹkyy, I. (1993). Istoriya Ukrayiny XX stolittya. Kyiv [in Ukrainian].
Narysy istoriyi Ukrayinsʹkoyi revolyutsiyi 1917-1921 rr. (2012). (Vol.2). Kyiv [in Ukrainian].
Pavlyuk, O. (2000). Ukrayinsʹko-polʹsʹkyy soyuz i polityka SSHA shchodo UNR u 1920 r. Ukrayinsʹkyy istorychnyy zhurnal, 6, 3-16 [in Ukrainian].
Piskun, V. (2020). Stavlennya naddnipryansʹkykh politychnykh kil do Varshavsʹkoyi uhody. Przegląd Wschodni, XVI, 1 (61), 61-76 [in Ukrainian].
Plazova, T. (2005). Ukrayinsʹkyy Partyzansʹko-Povstansʹkyy Shtab ta yoho uchastʹ v orhanizatsiyi antybilʹshovytsʹkoyi borotʹby v Ukrayini (1920-1921). Doctor's thesis. Lʹviv [in Ukrainian].
Popenko, Ya. (2006). Dyplomatychni vzayemyny Ukrayinsʹkoyi Narodnoyi Respubliky z krayinamy Antanty za doby Dyrektoriyi (lystopad 1918 - 1921 rr.). Extended abstract of PhD thesis. Zaporizhzhya [in Ukrainian].
Radchenko, L. (1997). Natsionalʹno-demokratychna revolyutsiya v Ukrayini 1917-1920 rokiv u novitniy vitchyznyaniy ta zarubizhniy literaturi. PhD thesis. Kharkiv [in Ukrainian].
Rublʹov, O., & Reyent, O. (1999). Ukrayinsʹki vyzvolʹni zmahannya 1917-1921 rr. Kyiv [in Ukrainian].
Rukkas, A. (2019). Stvorennya ta diyalʹnistʹ orhaniv viysʹkovo-dyplomatychnoho predstavnytstva UNR v Polʹshchi (1919-1921 rr.), Ukrayina i Polʹshcha: Shlyakhamy mizhderzhavnykh vzayemyn : zb. nauk. pratsʹ z nahody 100-richchya vstanovlennya polʹsʹko-ukrayinsʹkykh dyplomatychnykh vidnosyn. Kyiv [in Ukrainian].
Rukkas, A. (2020) Razem z wojskiem polskim. Armia Ukraińskiej Republiki Ludowej w 1920 roku. Warszawa [in Polish].
Rukkas, A.O. (2016). Razom z polʹsʹkym viysʹkom: Armiya Ukrayinsʹkoyi Narodnoyi Respubliky 1920 r. (struktura, orhanizatsiya, chyselʹnistʹ, uniforma). Kyiv [in Ukrainian].
Savchenko, V. (2000). Avantyurysty hrazhdanskoy voyny. Ystorycheskoe yssledovanye. Kharʹkov [in Russian].
Savchenko, V. (2006). Symon Petlyura. Kharʹkov [in Russian].
Serhiychuk, V. (2002). Neusvidomlennya Ukrayiny. Stavlennya svitu do ukrayinsʹkoyi derzhavnosti: pohlyad u 1917-1921 roky z analizom sʹohodennya. Lʹviv [in Ukrainian].
Serhiychuk, V. (2010). Nadiya i rozcharuvannya ukrayinstva. Do 90-richchya pidpysannya Varshavsʹkoho dohovoru mizh Ukrayinsʹkoyu Narodnoyu Respublikoyu i Richchyu Pospolytoyu Polʹsʹkoyu. Kyiv [in Ukrainian].
Shamrayeva, V. (2003). Mizhnarodni vidnosyny UNR chasiv Dyrektoriyi. Extended abstract of PhD thesis. Kyiv [in Ukrainian].
Slyusarenko, P. (2002). Armiya Ukrayinsʹkoyi Narodnoyi Respubliky u rosiysʹko-polʹsʹkiy viyni 1920 roku. ZB. Nauk. Pratsʹ Viysʹkovoho humanitarnoho instytutu Natsionalʹnoyi akademiyi oborony Ukrayiny, 6 (31), 50-57 [in Ukrainian].
Slyusarenko, P. (2002). Diyeva Armiya Ukrayinsʹkoyi Narodnoyi Respubliky v Pershomu Zymovomu pokhodi. Voyenna istoriya, 5-6, 94-99 [in Ukrainian].
Slyusarenko, P. (2003). Ukrayinsʹka 3-ya Zalizna Striletsʹka dyviziya v rosiysʹko-polʹsʹkiy viyni 1920 r. Visnyk akademiyi pratsi i sotsialʹnykh vidnosyn Federatsiyi profspilok Ukrayiny. 5 (24), 189-195 [in Ukrainian].
https://doi.org/10.3138/ttr.24.1.189
Slyusarenko, P. (2004). Boyovyy shlyakh 6-yi sichovoyi striletsʹkoyi dyviziyi chasiv rosiysʹko-polʹsʹkoyi viyny 1920 r. Visnyk akademiyi pratsi i sotsialʹnykh vidnosyn Federatsiyi profspilok Ukrayiny, 2 (26), 190-196 [in Ukrainian].
Slyusarenko, P. (2006). Armiya Ukrayinsʹkoyi Narodnoyi Respubliky v umovakh borotʹby za ukrayinsʹku derzhavnistʹ (veresenʹ 1919 - lystopad 1920 rr.). Extended abstract of PhD thesis. Kyiv [in Ukrainian].
Smoliy, V. (2020). Lyst z nahody vidkryttya mizhnarodnoyi konferentsiyi prysvyachenoyi 100-litt. Varshavsʹkoyi uhody 1920 roku. Przegląd Wschodni, XVI, 1 (61), 37-39 [in Ukrainian].
Sojusz Piłsudski-Petlura. Dokumenty i materiały. (2020). Warszawa-Kijów [in Ukrainian].
Soldatenko, V. (1999). Ukrayinsʹka revolyutsiya: kontseptsiya ta istoriohrafiya (1918-1920). Kyiv [in Ukrainian].
Soldatenko, V. (1999). Ukrayinsʹka revolyutsiya. Istorychnyy narys. Kyiv [in Ukrainian].
Soldatenko, V. (2008). Novitni tendentsiyi y aktualʹni problemy istoriohrafichnoho osvoyennya protsesiv revolyutsiynoyi doby 1917-1920 rr. v Ukrayini. Ukrayinsʹkyy istorychnyy zhurnal, 1, 75-88 [in Ukrainian].
Soldatenko, V. (2010). Ukrayina v revolyutsiynu dobu. (Vol.4). Kyiv [in Ukrainian].
Solovyova, V. (1999). Dyplomatychni predstavnytstva Ukrayinsʹkoyi Narodnoyi Respubliky v derzhavakh Tsentralʹnoyi Yevropy doby Dyrektoriyi (1918 - 1920 rr.). Extended abstract of PhD thesis. Zaporizhzhya [in Ukrainian].
Sribnyak, I. (1995). Symon Petlyura na choli derzhavy ta viysʹka: Do pytannya pro polʹsʹko-ukrayinsʹki vzayemyny 1919-1920 rokiv. Symon Petlyura ta ukrayinsʹka natsionalʹna revolyutsiya. Kyiv [in Ukrainian].
Sribnyak, I. (2000). Poloneni ta internovani voyaky-ukrayintsi v Yevropi (1914 - 1924 rr.) Extended abstract of Doctor's thesis. Kyiv [in Ukrainian].
Sribnyak, I. (2019). Kalish - tsentr hromadsʹko-politychnoho zhyttya ukrayinsʹkykh kombatantiv u Polʹshchi (persha polovyna 1920-kh rr.): za materialamy novykh rozshukiv u polʹsʹkykh ta ukrayinsʹkykh arkhivoskhovyshchakh. Ukrayina i Polʹshcha: Shlyakhamy mizhderzhavnykh vzayemyn : zb. nauk. pratsʹ z nahody 100-richchya vstanovlennya polʹsʹko-ukrayinsʹkykh dyplomatychnykh vidnosyn. nauk. Kyiv [in Ukrainian].
Stopchak, M. (2004). Ukrayinsʹko-polʹsʹka viysʹkovo-politychna uhoda 1920 r. v otsintsi ukrayinsʹkoyi istoriohrafiyi. Ucrainica Polonica: materialy Mizhnar. nauk. konf. Polyaky na Volyni: rezulʹtaty interdystsyplinarnykh doslidzhen [in Ukrainian].
Stopchak, M. (2005). Formuvannya zovnishnʹoyi polityky Dyrektoriyi UNR: do istoriohrafiyi problemy. Visnyk Kyyivsʹkoho natsionalʹnoho linhvistychnoho universytetu, 10, 8-92 [in Ukrainian].
Stopchak, M. (2005). Varshavsʹka uhoda v ukrayinsʹkiy istoriohrafiyi. Ukrayina dyplomatychna, 6, 450-465 [in Ukrainian].
Stopchak, M. (2010). Utvorennya i diyalʹnistʹ Dyrektoriyi Ukrayinsʹkoyi Narodnoyi Respubliky (1918-1920 rr.): Istoriohrafich. Narys. Vinnytsya [in Ukrainian].
Stopchak, M. (2011). Utvorennya i diyalʹnistʹ Dyrektoriyi Ukrayinsʹkoyi Narodnoyi Respubliky (1918-1920): istoriohrafiya problemy. Extended abstract of Doctor's thesis. Kyiv [in Ukrainian].
Symonenko, R., & Tabachnyk, D. (2007). Ukrayinsʹko-polʹsʹki vidnosyny ta borotʹba za yednistʹ Ukrayiny: XIX - poch. XX st.: Narysy. Kyiv [in Ukrainian].
Tereshchenko, Yu. (1999). Varshavsʹkyy dohovir 1920 r. i yoho otsinka ukrayinsʹkoyu dyplomatiyeyu. Symon Petlyura u konteksti Ukrayinsʹkykh natsionalʹno-vyzvolʹnykh zmahanʹ. Fastiv [in Ukrainian].
Tymchenko, R. (2011). Varshavsʹka uhoda 1920 r.: dolya Skhidnoyi Halychyny. Ukrayinsʹkyy istorychnyy zbirnyk, 14, 80-88 [in Ukrainian].
Varhatyuk, S. (1996). Varshavsʹki perehovory dyplomatychnoyi misiyi UNR. Nova polityka, 2, 53-54 [in Ukrainian].
Varhatyuk, S. (1996). Zovnishnya polityka Dyrektoriyi UNR. PhD thesis. Kyiv [in Ukrainian].
Verstyuk, V. (2005). Soyuz Yu. Pilsudsʹkoho-S.Petlyury 1920 r. v suchasniy ukrayinsʹkiy istoriohrafiyi. Naukovi zapysky natsionalʹnoho universytetu Kyyevo-Mohylyansʹka akademiya, 41: Istorychni nauky, 61-65 [in Ukrainian].
Verstyuk, V. (2020). Soyuz Pilsudsʹkoho - Petlyury v istoriyi borotʹby za ukrayinsʹku derzhavnistʹ. Ukrayinsʹkyy istorychnyy zhurnal, 2, 4-21 [in Ukrainian].
Vidnyanskyj, S. (2004). Ukrayinsʹko-polʹsʹki vidnosyny u 1918-1921 rr. v suchasniy ukrayinsʹkiy istoriohrafiyi. Nad Dniprom i Visloyu: Materialymizhnarodnoyi naukovoyi konferentsiyi Ukrayina i Polʹshcha u vyzvolʹnykh zmahannyakh XIX - poch. XX st. Kyiv, 5 lystopada 2003 r. Kyiv [in Ukrainian].
Vidnyanskyj, S. (2017). Varshavsʹkyy dohovir 1920 roku v otsintsi suchasnoyi ukrayinsʹkoyi istoriohrafiyi. Ukrayina Dyplomatychna, 18, 91-100 [in Ukrainian].
Vidnyanskyj, S., & Kalinchyk, V. (2007). Ukrayinsʹko-polʹsʹki vidnosyny 1917-1926 rr.: suchasna ukrayinsʹka istoriohrafiya. Naukovyy visnyk Derzhavnoho pedahohichnoho universytetu im. Lesi Ukrayinky. Istorychni Nauky, 1, 44-51 [in Ukrainian].
Yablonsʹkyy, V. (1998). Dyrektoriya UNR: formuvannya zasad ukrayinsʹkoyi derzhavnosti v 1918-1920 rr. PhD thesis. Kyiv [in Ukrainian].
Zadunaysʹkyy, V. (1995). Zbroyni syly UNR (1917-1920). PhD thesis. Donetsʹk [in Ukrainian].
Zaretsʹka, T. (2001). Ukrayinsʹko-polʹsʹki vidnosyny v period vidnovlennya derzhavnosti Polʹshchi. 1918-1919 rr. Ukrayina i Polʹshcha - stratehichne partnerstvo na zlami tysyacholitʹ: Istoriya. Sʹohodennya. Maybutnya perspektyva. (Vol.1). Kyiv [in Ukrainian].
Zaretsʹka, T. (2002). Vidnosyny Dyrektoriyi Ukrayinsʹkoyi Narodnoyi Respubliky z Polʹsʹkoyu Respublikoyu (1919-1920 rr.). Mìžnarodnì zv'âzki Ukraïni: naukovì pošuki ì znahìdki - International relations of Ukraine: scientific searches and findings, 11, 76-92 [in Ukrainian].
Zaretsʹka, T. (2007). Yuzef Pilsudsʹkyy i Ukrayina. Kyiv [in Ukrainian].
Zashkilʹnyak, L., & Krykun, M. (2002). Istoriya Polʹshchi. Vid naydavnishykh chasiv do nashykh dniv. Lʹviv [in Ukrainian].
Zaszkilniak, L. (2020) Kilka uwag o książce: Sojusz Piłsudski-Petlura. Dokumenty i materiały. Red. nauk. Jan Pisuliński, Witalij Skalski. Przegląd Wschodni, XVI, 1 (61), 125-132 [in Ukrainian].
Downloads
Published
How to Cite
Issue
Section
License
Copyright (c) 2024 Vitalii Borymskyi
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivatives 4.0 International License.
ISSN 
ISSN 
